Panama City - summary of day 5
Date : 04/12/2016
The world's largest anti-corruption gathering, 29 November - 4 December 2016, Panama City
IACC - Day 3
Corruption is the abuse of entrusted power for private gain. What makes this 17th International Anti-Corruption Conference different from all previous ones? Take the following case. You will see how easy it is to fool the world around you:
1. A public servant ‘helps’ a development company to obtain a construction permit, in return for a share in that development company. The sanction on this type of corruption is 10-15 years’ imprisonment, both for the payer and the receiver of the advantage.
2. To avoid detection, the public servant will not hold that share in his own name. He visits an offshore law firm one morning, and instructs them to setup two offshore companies for him, each in a different jurisdiction. The offshore companies will not be directed in his name but by trustees. If the public servant pays an additional fee to the offshore law firm, they will not disclose his identity as the real ultimate beneficial owner (UBO) of the offshore companies, but instead will use a fake identity.
3. The development company will not pay its annual dividends directly to the public servant but to the shareholding offshore company. This 1st offshore company will stream-up its profits to the 2nd offshore company and the remaining profit is available to the public servant.
4. Given the low operating costs of offshore constructions and high income tax rates, the tax advantage easily outweighs the costs. The public servant can use the same offshore construction to channel kickbacks from other bribes.
In fact, it only needs a criminal mind to do this, not even a criminal organisation. Before the Panama Papers we were unaware that well known individuals and organisations are using offshore constructions to hide illicit financial flows: companies, high net-worth individuals, football players, politicians, high-ranked public servants. Today we also know that offshore is worth $3 trillion, largely of criminal nature. Now we realise how big the push back against proper law enforcement in this area really is. That’s what makes the combat of corruption so difficult.
TI’s famous Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) assesses the risk of bribery of public officials per country. It shows poor scores for the south and the east. The CPI does not tell us where that money is subsequently stored and spent. The north and the west, yes. A speaker from Carnegie Endowment questioned why there is no powerful anti-corruption NGO to address this in the US - which is probably the largest tax haven in the world. It makes you think. And that is the best reason to attend conferences.
Brendan Sinnott and Evert-Jan Lammers, 4 December 2016